Should I Rent or Buy?

Post by 
Birgo

Is there a good answer to this question? We know a common belief – buy your home because you’ll pay it off over time, and in 30 years, you’ll have something to show for it. Renting is just throwing your money away, right?
According to CNBC, buying is the better option in today’s real estate market. When looking at the cost of renting over 35 years vs. the average price of a home in San Francisco, renting will cost almost a million dollars more!
Let’s take a closer look at that thought. In San Francisco, if you rented from age 25 to age 60, you would pay $2.5 million. On the other hand, you could buy a home for $1.6 million. It looks like buying a home is much cheaper, but there are a few things that this comparison leaves out.

The Real Cost of Ownership

When renting, you have a single home cost: your monthly rent. Buying a home, however, comes with a basket of expenses. First, the purchase price isn’t what you end up paying; add in 30 years of interest and your home will end up costing more than double what you bought it for. Insurance, upkeep, property taxes, and homeowners association fees will bring up the cost too.
So, on a monthly basis, what does the difference come out to? According to Nerdwallet, homeowners in Pennsylvania pay 63% more than renters each month. This is based on a median cost of ownership of $1,414 and a median rent of $868 within the state.
What does the extra $546 that PA homeowners pay go towards? The homeownership part, of course. That $546 a month will pay down the balance on your house. By pairing your monthly payment with a $25,000 down payment, you could own in 30 years a home that cost $100,000.

Is a Home an Investment?

Something isn’t right about this though- a home is supposed to be an investment, but by putting in over $200,000 over the course of 3 decades, you’re only getting $100,000 in home value. Yes, home prices could appreciate, but that’s speculative. Is there a better option?
If you were to rent instead of own, you could immediately free up that $546, along with all the other expenses of owning a home. You’ll also still have the $25,000 in your pocket that would’ve gone towards a down payment, but what could you do with that instead?
The simplest thing to do with this money would be to invest it in equities. To compare this investment, we’ll just consider a 3% dividend, which you could easily find. We’ll also disregard appreciation in the stock market, since we did the same for homes. By starting with $25,000 and putting in $546 each month, in 30 years you’ll have more than $370,000! In terms of guaranteed value, renting and investing takes the cake.
But for the sake of realism, let’s consider how much your house or stock portfolio would actually end up being worth. According to CNBC, US home prices have risen 6 times in value from 1970 to 2000. That means that a $100,000 home could be worth $600,000 in 30 years. Having put in $200,000 over those 30 years, your money would have gained 3 times its value.
On the other hand, in the same time period, the S&P 500 rose 14 times in value, gaining an average of 9.2% each year. At this rate, investing that $25,000 down payment and contributing $546 every month could leave you with over $1.3 Million in 30 years! With an even amount of speculation on both sides, renting and investing still makes more sense.

Takeaways

The difference between buying stocks and paying a mortgage: earning interest vs. paying interest. Anyone who brags about what they paid for their home 30 years ago is covering up their disappointment in missing out on stock market gains.
Look past the “American Dream” and think, does buying a home really make sense?

Keep Up With Birgo

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
THere's More

Posts You Might Also Like

Birgo Realty

Must-Listen to Real Estate Podcasts | Marketing, Real Estate Investing and More!

As a real estate agent, investor, or someone who works in the real estate industry, it’s important to keep up-to-date with the latest industry news and trends. With there now being over 850,000 active podcasts, it can be difficult figuring out which ones are worth your time. We’ve listed some of the most popular podcasts with the Birgo Realty team. From real estate investing to marketing, we mention a slew of podcasts we think you’ll enjoy listening to.
Birgo Realty

Greensburg Business List | Your Guide to Greensburg

New to the Greensburg area? Or maybe you’re already a resident and just looking for things to do! Whatever the case, we’ve got your back. This charming and historic city offers the best people, places, and experiences. Below we’ve compiled a list of our favorite local Greensburg businesses ranging from coffee shops, hair salons, restaurants, and more so you can experience everything this city has to offer.
Birgo Realty

Safety Tips for Living Alone

Being independent doesn’t always have to be scary; living alone can mean newfound freedom and opportunities to explore your curiosity. To help you feel peace of mind and secure in your new neighborhood, we’re sharing our top safety tips for living alone.
Birgo Realty

Q&A With Birgo Real Estate Photographer Brett Hammon

Birgo photographer Brett Hammon answers some of the most pressing real estate photography questions that will help anyone looking to get started in the field. Everything from how to book a job to what time of day is best for shooting is discussed. Be sure to read our other real estate photography article for further tips and tricks!
Birgo Realty

Real Estate Photography: Tips, Tricks, & How to Get Started

Are you a photography buff but haven’t yet dipped your toes into real estate photography? Or are you a photography newbie and just starting out? You’re in luck, because we at Birgo Realty want to help. We're exploring tips and tricks to get started so that in no time, you'll be featured on the cover of Architectural Digest.